Planes Trains Essay

Essay on Comparing Trains and Planes as Means of Transportation

558 Words3 Pages

Comparing Trains and Planes as Means of Transportation

From the dawn of time, man has followed his urge to travel; sometimes neglecting the enjoyment of the journey in pursuit of the destination. Although two of the favorable means of passenger transportation - the plane and the train - accomplish the task of arriving at a destination, there are distinct differences in their capacity for comfort, time, scenic value, and safety.

To entice the weary traveler, accustomed and outraged by the rough, tiresome, and jolting rides on planes and trains, improvements have been made over the decades to pamper the passenger. Mechanical changes and physical changes enhance the traveling experience. Although airplane seats are space-efficient to…show more content…

Dining aboard is a feast for the eyes as well as the palate. Crisp white linens, fine crystal, and delicate china adorn the tables in the spacious dining cars. Uniformed staff pour carafes of fine wine of bubbling soda into genuine glasses. If a traveler is interested in creature comforts, the train is the idea choice.

On the other hand, if time is of the essence, planes are far superior to trains. At speeds up to 500 MPH, a plane can travel across country in hours; trains travel like snail in comparison with speeds of 45-100 MPH. If speed is important, then the plane is the wisest choice.

However, if a traveler is interested in enjoying the scenic pleasure of traveling, trains have a distinct advantage over planes. From high in the sky, the earth resembles a miniature ant farm. Glancing out the scratchy, thick plastic window, tiny moving vehicles appear like scurrying insects across clearly marked human paths. At night, millions of twinkling lights decorate the land like the holiday season. The scenery is quite different while traveling the iron rails. Outside the tinted picture windows, a moving masterpiece - the luscious countryside dotted by quaint buildings, the gently rolling hills, and the peaceful blur of nature. For scenic beauty alone, the train is an excellent choice in transportation.

Regarding safety, travelers who suffer from Aerophobia or

Show More

The category of “Thanksgiving movies” is a select one indeed, but it is not meant as faint praise to crown John Hughes’ 1987 film, Planes, Trains and Automobiles, the greatest Thanksgiving film ever made. On the surface a carefree comedy, the movie carries a subtle Christian subtext and a message whose deep pathos is not fully revealed until its penultimate scene.

The movie tells the story of Neal Page (played by Steve Martin), a middle-aged, well-to-do advertising executive, who is trying to get home from New York to spend Thanksgiving with his family at his home in an up-scale Chicago suburb. His journey quickly becomes a nightmare when he meets Del Griffith (played by John Candy) a boorish, traveling shower-curtain-ring salesman, who attempts to befriend the self-centered Page. Griffith first inadvertently steals Page’s taxi, then ends up seated next to him on a plane that is grounded by a snowstorm, and next proceeds to bumble in nearly every attempt to help Page get home by, variously, train, truck, and automobile.

The interplay between the staid and trim Martin and the gregarious and rotund Candy makes for some hilarious and unforgettable scenes: Page and Griffith are forced to share a hotel bed together and wake up to find that they are cuddling in their sleep, dreaming of their wives (“Those aren’t pillows!”); Griffith mistakenly drives the wrong way down a highway, dismissing two motorists’ shouted warning that they “are going the wrong way” with the retort, “how do they know where we’re going?”; Griffith’s carelessness results in the pair’s rental car going up in flames, yet Griffith is nonplussed and pilots the skeletal vehicle down the interstate, telling a police officer who stops them that he indeed deems the car “safe for highway travel.”

But beneath all the hijinks lurk the messages of charity and redemption. Page, intent on getting back to his family, is oblivious to the fact that Griffith does not seem to be going anywhere in particular at Thanksgiving time. There are subtle hints sprinkled throughout the film that something is awry in Del’s life. He lugs around a large trunk, and though he mentions his wife Marie more than once and places a framed picture of her next to his hotel beds, he never checks in with her by phone, as Page does several times with his wife.

By modern standards, Page would be seen as a good man. He is a hard worker who has provided a comfortable living to his family. He is a good husband and father, who is eager to get home to his wife and children, who obviously adore him. One would guess that Neal Page gives regularly to local charities, holds doors for ladies, and tips waiters generously.

But it is in his interaction with the working-class Griffith that Page’s inner nature is revealed. For most of the film, he wants nothing to do the oafish salesman. Early on when sharing a hotel room with the slovenly Griffith, he is driven to his wit’s end and explodes at the salesman: “When you’re telling these little stories, here’s an idea: Have a point! It makes it so much more interesting for the listener.” In the first indication that this movie is deeper than a typical slapstick comedy, Griffith is brought nearly to tears by Page’s words: “Yeah, you’re right: I talk too much. But I also listen too much. I could be a cold-hearted cynic like you, but I don’t like to hurt people’s feelings. I like me. My wife likes me. My customers like me. ‘Cause I’m the real article. What you see is what you get.”

Key to the success of the film is this refusal of writer-director Hughes to make cardboard characters out of Griffith and Page. The shower-curtain-ring salesman, despite his boorishness, is aware that he is a “blabbermouth” who can annoy others. Page is also not one-dimensional. He is an everyman in his understandable desire to avoid the loquacious  and overbearing Griffith, yet his face shows the regret he feels when he realizes he has deeply wounded Griffith in the hotel room scene described above.

Griffith’s essential goodness eventually begins to affect Page. When they end up being forced to abandon the same broken-down train, Page spots Griffith struggling to drag his oversize trunk across a rough field. Page shakes his head in resignation and picks up one end of the trunk. One is reminded of the reluctant Simon helping Jesus carry his cross. Near the end of the movie, when Griffith is forced to sleep in the burned-out car during a snowstorm, Page invites Griffith to share his hotel room. Over many mini-bottles of liquor, the two men joke and philosophize in a realistic scene of alcohol-fueled male bonding. Page seems to finally appreciate Griffith for what he is: a well-meaning, unpretentious, good soul, who simply “goes with the flow, like a twig on the shoulders of a mighty stream.”

After they part ways on a Chicago train platform, Page, who already realizes that Griffith has made him “a little wiser,” has time to recall and laugh at the pair’s misadventures. In doing so, it finally dawns on Page that Griffith does not have a home. Hurrying back to the station where he left the traveling salesman, Page finds Griffith sitting alone on a bench. “You said you were going home. What are you doing here?” Griffith  replies: “I don’t have a home, Neal. Marie’s been dead for eight years.” In the movie’s final scene, Page and Griffith, each holding an end of the trunk, which it is now clear symbolizes the pain of loss that Griffith silently bares, walk up to Page’s home. “I won’t stay long,” Griffith offers. “Maybe I’ll just say hi, then be on my way.” “Just come on,” is Page’s reply.

Page’s act of charity in bringing Griffith to his home for Thanksgiving brings a heartwarming, and unexpected, conclusion to Planes, Trains and Automobiles. A lighthearted romp at first blush, at bottom it tells the story of how the example of simple goodness can be transformational. Genuinely intent on helping a complete stranger get home to his loved ones, Del Griffith, shower-curtain-ring salesman, does much more than that: He saves a soul.

Books mentioned in this essay may be found in The Imaginative Conservative Bookstore


Published: Nov 23, 2012

One thought on “Planes Trains Essay

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *